Blog
Tech

Four messengers that are better than WhatsApp

Today, messengers have mostly replaced SMS messages with WhatsApp being in the vanguard and having acquired over one billion active users to date. In most cases, the app works flawlessly and handles fairly well. So all is good, right? Hardly! WhatsApp's reputation has received quite a few dents over the years not least due to its acquisition by Facebook - and reports of a linking between Facebook and WhatsApp user profiles to consolidate their databases. Meta data (Who talked to whom?) is still considered a gold mine by data collectors and the struggle to create e ver denser user profiles is ongoing. Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram, also owned by Facebook, already enjoy a close cooperation. On top of that, WhatsApp is also regularly dogged by security issues. Time to start looking for viable WhatsApp replacements!

No cellphone without a messenger

Edward Snowden's favorite: Signal

The mere mentioning of Signal is often enough to bring a smile to the faces of computer scientists. This open-source messenger had already been using encrypted protocols long before WhatsApp ever considered them. Signal is free, user-friendly and not only supports instant messaging but also voice / video calling and file sharing. All communication is protected by strong end-to-end encryption so listening in on conversations or intercepting files is next to impossible. Signal even goes one step further by offering "self-destructing" messages that delete themselves automatically after a while. Since privacy is paramount in Signal, there's no built-in backup feature, after all, backups could fall into the wrong hands. Even phone numbers, essential to establish a connection between participants, are transmitted in encrypted form making tracing calls impossible. Edward Snowden and other international security experts openly endorse the app because Open Whisper Systems, the organization behind it, i s entirely funded through donations and grants. Signal is definitely worth checking out!

Good news from Switzerland: Threema

For under two euros, Switzerland-based Threema GmbH offers a discrete messenger of the same name. The company has no interest in meta data and created user groups and contact lists never leave their users' phones. Threema GmbH likes to point out they couldn't listen in on conversations even if they wanted to because, once again, all communication is fully encrypted through strong end-to-end encryption. Telephony, text and voice messages as well as file sharing are supported. Aside from that, handling is easy and the app offers neat bonus features like group voting (in case you and your friends need to decide which beer to get for your next party). And don't forget the site advantage: Switzerland not only has great chocolate but also one of the strictest data privacy laws in the world. Still, I'd recommend Threema only to experienced users as the initial setup involves the creation of a unique user ID which may confuse especially beginners.

Available across devices: Wire

Insider tip: Wire

Here's yet another messenger from Switzerland. It's open-source, well-designed, secure and free (for private use). Once again, all communication is encrypted, meta data anonymized and message content only present on the recipient's and your device. Wire supports video calling and even allows the creation of two separate user profiles, e.g. one for business and one for private use. It's a great and fun platform to share content with others. Just be aware that, should you share your data through third-party apps (Spotify, Youtube, etc.), security and anonymity will suffer as your data will be routed through less secure channels. I particularly liked the outstanding call quality. In addition, Wire Swiss GmbH offers desktop clients for all major operating systems which is great! Also, the user interface looks very tidy and professional so the app's definitely worth a shot.

Data protection officers on the run: Telegram

Telegram is so secure that is has been banned by the Russian government. While some may consider this a seal of quality, overall, it's a rather sad story with one of the founders, Pawel Durow, having to leave the country due to pressure from intelligence agencies. Telegram offers different forms on encryption. "Secret chat" is the most secure option and relies, you guessed it, on end-to-end encryption. Regular chats use classic client-server / server-client encryption and could potentially be read by the developer. Unlike the other alternatives, Telegram's default messages are cloud-based and can be accessed on any of the user's connected devices. The user interface is rather playful with support for stickers and games and seems primarily targeted at a younger audience. Because of the cloud integration and the weaker encryption for regular chats, Telegram is not my first pick on this list - over 100 million users seem to be having a more relaxed view of the situation, though.

Is it worth switching?

Transitional pains

Installing one the above apps is just the first step in the shift from old messenger to new. The problem: all of your contacts also have to make the switch or else you'll have no-one to chat with. This may require a fair amount of convincing! After all, people likely have gotten used to the amenities of WhatsApp and we're all creatures of habit! Switching means work and especially less technophile users who had a difficult time learning WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger may be rather disinclined to start all over again. Sure, Skype, Google Hangouts and Facebook Messenger (which already have a high adoption rate and resemble WhatsApp the most) are easier to pick up but they are also just as avid data collectors. No viable alternatives there! Why not take the time to discuss the above alternatives with your family and friends? Your privacy and security are certainly worth the few extra minutes it takes to install and set them up!

What I would like to know: do you use messengers other than WhatsApp (or Facebook Messenger)? Did I miss any other great alternatives?

Pic 2: © Wire Swiss GmbH

11 comments
  • M

    Great article as usual, thank you .... but I have a slightly different problem which you might think about commenting on :-

    I am out of cellphone coverage for all the networks (yes there are patches of the UK still with no mobile signal !).

    With two stage verification now becoming very common indeed and now with most Covid alert apps needing a mobile signal to work properly, it is a real bind !!! You just can't train banks to use whatsapp and if you go a bit overdrawn (perish the thought) it could be embarrassing and even costly.

    I have excellent broadband speed thanks to a certain cable provider and I also have voice over IP so I can make and receive mobile calls over wifi BUT not texts!!. I have heard that EE can provide texts over wifi but don't know how. There must be many in the same position. Any ideas ??

  • R

    I have just loaded Wire but my friend in NZ is having problems installing it. Perhaps it was Germany getting beat today :)

    Thanks for all your blogs Sven. There's always something of interest.

    You´re welcome! Wire is made in Switzerland. Switzerland advanced in the World Cup so it should work. :)

  • D

    Wasn't it all very intentional Sven? When Microsoft killed Live Messenger the writing was on the wall. Separate people and make it more difficult to in touch via audio, text and video unless you want to pay to do so.

    I've never given Signal a run to see how it flies. I miss the morning video calls from people I know around the world. Thank you and apologies for being late due to higher than usual volume of email.

    No need to apologize. :) I appreciate every nice comment no matter when it arrives. It was the end of ICQ that caused upheaval among my friends and relatives. You’re right, every time you transition from one program to the next, a few contacts are lost along the way.

  • D

    With your and some of your respondents' recommendations, there's a big choice of messengers to choose from.

    The problem - as you rightly point out, Sven - is that unless all of your contacts are on the same platform as you, you'll have nobody to talk to!

    It's like the man who had the very first telephone. Who did he call?!

  • C

    all good and well, but i am urged to use the app used by the contact I want to reach...

    On a given moment Viber was on my phone only for 1 person I knew, and he used Whatsapp and Facebook as well. Guess what? I killed that Viber app!!!

  • L

    Thanks for the alternatives Sven,

    That final paragraph pretty much sums up the challenge that alternatives face, 'convincing' people to leave their beloved Spybook, errm, Facebook walled garden.

    I'm in China, which has its Internet challenges, and by far the most popular messenger is WeChat, probably followed by QQ. I am sure these apps track people, and there have been reports of messages being censored or even 'lost' if they are deemed to mention sensitive keywords. But over here, people seem to shun any comments about being digitally stalked by the providers. They really are not aware of data collecting nor do they seem to care that the companies make milions from them.

    I think it will be hard to get people away from those apps because they have integrated payment systems, and they can send 'red envelopes' (gift money), to each other.

    There's a good reason I didn't include WeChat. :) While technically excellent, the app is severly lacking in data protection to put it mildly...

  • P

    Thanks as usual for interesting and useful info. What is your take on Line, security-wise? It is huge in Japan, simple to use and has excellent call quality.

    I haven't heard of Line but I'll check it out!

  • S

    I use "mysms". Both Android and Windows 10, which synch with each other.

    Sounds good. I'll take a look at mysms.

  • M

    What about the new features in Google Android messenger with the ability to message from a PC ?

    Which of the above allows sending & receiving messages offer wifi when not on range of cell phone signal ?

  • J

    Viber

  • m

    Hello

    Thanks to this powerful and useful application.All Software Ashampoo.

    With this powerful software, my Windows problems have been fixed.

    I hope you always succeed and win.

    Thank you and all Friends and colleagues.with your knowledge.

    Thank you very much..have nice day.

    Thank you for your positive feedback. It’s great that everything works fine. Have a nice day, too!

    Cheers, Mel

About Ashampoo
Users
22+ million
Downloads
500.000+ per month
World-wide
In over 160 countries
Experience
Over 25 years
Ashampoo icon