Blog
Tech

Four superior Windows Explorer replacements

As Windows advances, one important part of it remains as imperfect as ever: Windows Explorer. It may be enough to navigate around your files but if you value a little comfort or miss the old split-view (present up to Windows 95), you're out of luck. Why Microsoft doesn't offer a decent alternative is beyond me! Luckily, there are better, more feature rich and often free file managers out there - and one piece of software that has been painfully missed for over a decade is making a return!

Inconspicuous but important: file managers

Four windows and neat features: Q-Dir

Q-Dir is the Swiss army jackknife to move and copy mountains of data between folders. If you have multiple partitions, network drives or juggle a myriad of external disks, you'll quickly appreciate the feature set. Spread across four windows, Q-Dir saves up to 64 folder combinations as favorites for fast access. In addition, every window supports tab navigation to suit the needs of professional data jugglers. Folder contents can be exported as documents in various formats and different colors can be used for different file types for better readability. And since Q-Dir follows the design of default Windows applications, it doesn't take much getting used to.

Smart and with near limitless customization options: FreeCommander

This application has been around for quite some time and recently reached version XE 2018. It offers the classic two-window split view and is crammed with features - which may scare off some users with numerous icons hiding smart functions at every corner. The visuals, views and program behavior are highly customizable, giving the program a bit of an IKEA feeling as you slowly design your perfect file manager. Naturally, standard features like copying, moving, deleting and renaming files and folders are present but the program can do a lot more. For example, every window supports the classic tree view, image formats are previewable and, thanks to plugins, even compressed archives pose no problem. Comfort features like multiple file renaming, folder size calculations, secure file deletion and folder syncing are also built in. A lot of effort has been put into this program and it shows!

FreeCommander

The master of archives: Double Commander

Visually a little on the sober side but very tidy is a good way to describe Double Commander. As the name implies, the program also supports the two-window split pane view that pretty much everyone except Microsoft expects from a file manager these days. Handling file archives (7z, ZIP, ARJ, CAB, LZH and RAR) is where this program shines. With a powerful search option, files can not only be scanned for common parameters like size or creation date but also for embedded characters. If you can still remember what you wrote but forgot which document you put it in, this feature is for you. Renaming files with ease is another strength of the program with support for savable naming schemes for later use. The integrated FTP client, file splitter and sync feature are nice addons. And for those who love keyboard shortcuts: there's a shortcut for almost everything. Sounds like fun, right?

What software used to look like! What software used to look like!

A classic returns

Finally, we come to THE solution for traditionalists - and I mean traditional as in old school! Microsoft's Craig Wittenberg has an interesting hobby. He breathes new life into the file manager that originally came with Windows NT 4. The result looks and behaves exactly the way file managers looked and behaved back then, which may feel a little out of place on a Windows 10 machine, and yet it works! Suddenly, you feel reminded of pixelated resolutions, unintelligible icons and your first steps with Windows 3.11 - it's a flashback to the humble beginnings of modern PC GUIs. And since the project is open source, meaning the code is available to the public, newer and slicker versions will likely come out soon. If you're an inveterate nostalgic or on the lookout for a lean and fast file manager, this program is for you.

What I would like to know: Do you use third-party file managers or are you fully content with Windows Explorer? Did I miss any great free file managers?

If you were looking for Total Commander (still the Holy Grail for many): the program isn't free but certainly a great alternative.

38 comments
Page 2 of 2
  • K

    Count me in the Directory Opus crowd. Undoubtedly the most expensive, but it starts where PowerDesk left off all those years ago, and just keeps growing. Well worth the money, IMHO.

  • D

    Running Windows 8.1 my problems are Outlook Express and Windows Live Mail neither of which is now supported and keep giving problems.

    On the computer running Windows 10 the main problem is that Windows Media Centre is not supported and was deleted during the setup.

    Also what has happened to Opera?

  • E

    Hello Sven,

    Your input is as interesting as ever: love it!

    Though it's already been mentioned:

    1. Mr Ghisler's Total Commander still appears to be the choice of many users (professionals as well as hone ones), probably due to its maintaining the DOS-like access to its commands (for whoever likes to work that way); currently, it also sports a version for the smartphones (at least for Android - I don't know about iOS).

    2. This being said however, the "holy grail" of them all (though kind of expensive) appears to be Directory Opus - a lot of work has been invested in it to make it the union of all Swiss-knives in a single unit!

    Still, while obviously not perfect, Windows Explorer has come a long way, and its command ribbon for one, as well as the Quick Access to files and folders are quite useful (and not always found in alternatives!)

    Keep on the good work,

    Eric

    N.B.: For Bob Levy: PowerDesk HAS been brought to date and made compatible with Win10 (check < http://www.softcity.com/software/powerdesk-pro-9-162326?meta=pc-utilities&cat=multimedia&sub=Photo-Management > for more info.

  • D

    On your recommendation, Sven, I have just downloaded Q-Dir. Es ist wunbderbar!

    I wasn't really aware of the shortcomings of Windows Explorer until I saw thew possibilities offered by Q-Dir.

    Huge thanks for an excellent recommendation!

  • D

    Windows Explorer is a browser. I believe you are referring to File Explorer. Sad you put it in your prominent headline.

  • D

    Yet another is XYPlorer, which is multi functional, split screen, file search and all. A free version is available. MS is to lazy to develop another file manager.

  • M

    Okay, I've tried Q-Dir and it's not something I need. Now please tell me how to uninstall it when it doesn't appear in the programs list

    Hi Mike,

    By default, the program will appear in Settings > Apps & Features under Windows 10 after installation. However, there is a "Portable installation" option that only copies the program files to the specified target folder on your machine. In this case, you only need to delete that folder to uninstall the program.

  • A

    Years ago, I think it was in the days of DOS I used a file manager from Norton the had split screen and I could compare two files to see if there were any differences. It would show a list of the differences in each window. Do any of these products have a similar function?

  • S

    I'm surprised you didn't mention Explorer++, which can be found at https://explorerplusplus.com/

  • D

    When Norton stopped updating it's file manager I switched to Windows Commander (now Total Commander) and never looked back. It is shareware but you never have to pay for it if you don't want to. I paid for it as I think it's important to encourage people who do this kind of work to keep going.

  • B

    Powerdesk is still the best! Wish it was still supported.

  • D

    I've been using Directory Opus for many years. It has too many features to mention - so many that you'll just use a subset that match your needs. I first got it as a free version a long time ago and it still does everything I need. Look at it.

  • K

    You should really look at xplorer2 (squared); great product I have been using for about 8 years; pro version is worth the money too.

    Thanks for your comment! I’ll check it out.

About Ashampoo
Users
22+ million
Downloads
500.000+ per month
World-wide
In over 160 countries
Experience
Over 25 years
Ashampoo icon